The Proud Duck

The Proud Duck

Thoughts on policy, history, faith, baseball when I get around to it, waterfowl, and life in general by a junior attorney who'd much rather have Jonah Goldberg's job. Or possibly Darin Erstad's.

Archives

Friday, October 20, 2006

Logic from Iran's nasty little tyrant Mahmoud Ahmadinejad:

"If the Holocaust is real why are those who have the opposite opinion about it being arrested and jailed?"

I'm no fan of the laws in Europe that prohibit questioning the Holocaust -- history should always be open to debate, and even if the evidence for an occurrence is overwhelming, the answer to a crackpot who denies it is ridicule, not prosecution. History may not be a true science, but it partakes enough of scientific and academic methods that criminalizing getting the "wrong" result is not acceptable, and will inevitably put a damper on energetic inquiry. It's not a coincidence that the logic of criminalizing one's scientific opponents has spread to the global warming debate, for example, with at least one global-warming proponent advocating "Nuremberg trials" for global warming "deniers."

But back to A-Jad (like that? Like A-Rod, and a lot easier than typing "Ahmadinejad" and having to look up the spelling each time). Someone needs to ask the question back at him: "If Islam is real, why are those who have the opposite opinion about it being arrested and jailed -- or killed?" The penalty for apostasy in Iran, of course, is death. Add hypocrisy to the long list of the little bearded schmuck's vices.

posted by Thomas at 10:36 AM

4 comments

4 Comments:

Thats right. Demonize muslims. Way to go ya rightwing islamofascist.

By Anonymous, at 3:06 PM

That's right. Demonize ducks. Way to go, you mindless poultrynazi.

Dude, pay attention and I'll use small words. I'm addressing the logic of ONE particular world leader who happens to be Muslim. If you want to point to the place in my post where I said anything about ALL Muslims -- or even two -- have at it.

I'm criticizing Mahmoud Ahmadinejad for using absolutely appalling logic to argue that the Holocaust didn't happen. Do you agree with him? Or am I right to contradict the man?

And is it not true that under the Iranian legal code, apostasy is punished by death?

By Thomas, at 3:30 PM

You nutjobs will demonize anyone or anything to rationalize your own warped ideas. Come out of your angry dreamworld be a part of humanity.

By Anonymous, at 8:36 AM

OK, fine. Mahmound Ahmadinejad is a fine example of virtue and righteousness. His logic is impeccable. The Holocaust never happened -- it's all a Zionist plot. All those guys with Auschwitz tattoos on their arms are lying weasels and Israel needs to be wiped off the face of the earth, like the saintly Mr. Ahmadinejad says.

Happy?

By Thomas, at 9:51 AM