The Proud Duck

Thoughts on policy, history, faith, baseball when I get around to it, waterfowl, and life in general by a junior attorney who'd much rather have Jonah Goldberg's job. Or possibly Darin Erstad's.

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?
Thursday, January 11, 2007
 
I've said before that the greatest hardship poor Americans have to deal with is having to live with other poor Americans. That's not to say the poor are necessarily less "moral" than the wealthy -- there are plenty of rich people who are utterly wicked, as the Bible itself points out again and again, and who'd think nothing of stealing their own grandmother's life savings between rounds of golf. But the wealthy tend to keep their disorder private. Ken Lay may have been defrauding millions of people of their life savings, but I'm sure he was a nice enough neighbor, and very unlikely to steal your car stereo.

And having your car stereo stolen, your kid robbed at gunpoint, your daughter raped, etc. is probably the greatest suffering imposed by American poverty. By most objective measures, poor Americans' material standard of living -- based on living space and consumption of goods -- is comparable to the standard of living of many ordinary non-poor Europeans.

The problem is that economic inequality does matter in this one regard: Public disorder tends to become concentrated in those communities that are poorer relative to others, regardless of their absolute wealth. The reason for this is that public disorder arises largely from private disorder -- people's unwillingness to police themselves, leaving only the imperfect controls of the police to impose order. Private disorder is correlated with poverty; people with poor impulse controls aren't likely to be high achievers. People who are competent enough to rise in society will naturally prefer to leave disordered communities -- segregating them further as enclaves of lowlifes and making them even more disordered.

A liberal might say that the solution is then to eliminate economic inequality. She would be wrong. Eliminating economic inequality entirely is impossible, short of the full Harrison Bergeron treatment, since random contingency will always allocate talent, personality, and good fortune differently. And as long as even some inequality persists, people's natural inclination to self-segregate with people of equivalent class will persist, and the neighborhoods at the bottom will always be the roughest -- for the simple reason that people with sufficient means will always want to escape them. Thus, even with Sweden's relatively low economic inequality, there are of course still neighborhoods where a woman can't walk alone at night. (Those neighborhoods happen to be largely populated by Muslim immigrants, BTW, which is really starting to cheese the Swedes off, but that's another matter.)

Even though poverty is associated with disorder, with the poorer neighborhoods more disorderly than affluent ones, the absolute level of disorder in the poorest communities can vary. Cultures influence behavior. A culture that successfully imposes greater informal restraints on behavior will still have its poorest neighborhoods be the roughest ones -- but those roughest neighborhoods will be less disordered than the worst neighborhoods in a society whose culture does not impose such restraints. Thus, even though South Los Angeles and South Malmo (I'm guessing here) may lie at the bottom of America's and Sweden's respective wealth-and-order scales, South Malmo will be less disorderly than South LA -- because Swedes are less disorderly than Americans.

In other words, making America more like Sweden won't solve the problems many liberals claim it will -- because Americans aren't Swedes.
20 comments

20 Comments:

Licking the balls of right wing voodoo priests is unbecoming.

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 3:04 PM  

Being a right-wing voodoo priest myself, I hope that word doesn't get out.

I'm sticking a couple of pins in my anonymous voodoo doll right now. Feel it?

By Blogger Thomas, at 6:58 PM  

Joe Smith was a child molester and a rapist, just like the rest of you demon doctrine mormons.

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 5:40 PM  

Wow... it got awful quite in here when the truth is told about mormons.

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 12:00 PM  

http://prieslar.info/?search=seo+catalogs
http://prieslar.info/?search=samochody+sportowe
http://prieslar.info/?search=6+weidera+efekty
http://prieslar.info/?search=Propagacja+fizyka
http://prieslar.info/?search=6+weidera+na+brzuch
http://prieslar.info/?search=Jazda+na+maksa

By Blogger alex, at 5:32 PM  

Hey, landed on your blog, nice stuff. I found a cool new tool for our blogs... www.widgetmate.com It helps get latest news for our keywords directly on to our blog. I added it on mine. Worked like a charm.

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 9:10 AM  

WT heck? Mormon's? I read the article twice...did I miss something?

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 10:12 PM  

Very Nice Blog !
I Like This Very Much.
Methods of Modern Farming
Duck keeping

By Blogger Suporna Roy, at 6:57 AM  

ebsg [url=http://www.bootssay.com]cheap ugg[/url]
The 1st that must be done is you have to ask to switch it on and journey it. As long as they no then likely it's not necessarily in condition. If you are permitted to experience. Jump on and experience about for a couple of moments. Bring it in a couple of little slopes. Whether or not this addresses useful to you, then this means it flights properly.


ssau [url=http://www.bootswould.com]www.bootswould.com[/url]
NEW YORK (MarketWatch) - Ugg boot ugg trunk creator Deckers Out-of-doors Corp. (Terrace, US) tumbled 13% on Feb 5th soon after it stated rising cost of living in ugg fees would continue to hurt major prices this coming year. At garments cycle Gap Incorporated. (Navigation, US) , explains to you fell 4Per cent simply because it stated "some anxiety prevails" as to wherever solution expenses will land.


tclh [url=http://www.bootswould.com]uggs boots cheap[/url]
to raise financial support. Market admittance conditions match the travel and travel and leisure establishments and credit ratings rules vacation jobs, many forms of money to increase credit history support for, affordable financial loan period and bank loan rates. Qualified small and medium travel and leisure establishments can engage in preferential financial products. To own sources and marketplace likely, but a brief working difficulties of traveling organizations, loan companies, according to the conditions of try really hard to giving credit score assist. More help the financing of travel and leisure corporations and also other credit rating advancement ensure system, credit rating assurance companies to enhance the kinds of vacation companies and tourism tasks assurance efforts. Expand the capital options for tourism corporations, loan companies, business improvement within the panoramic spot offers the appropriate to operate and depend on citation revenue and other secured car loans organization. Motivate medium and small travel and leisure establishments and countryside tourism organization staff to ensure realization of communal joint microfinance. Help experienced businesses to concern brief-time period financing expenses tourist, company securities and choice-term notices, and definitely stimulate experienced travel and leisure corporations within the SME aboard and Jewel funding. Motivate consumer banks involved in the pilot process to present credit score providers to travel related. Finance companies also to positively promote tourist businesses to formulate means of enterprise cooperation, explore the creation of vacation intake needs for financial products, to improve travel and leisure products and services bank card.

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 8:27 PM  

Thіs will ρrevent the ԁоugh from getting stucκ tightly
to the surfaсе of the ρizza pan.

Αll уou haνe tо dο іn order
to obtаіn these cοuрonѕ iѕ tо go tο the inteгnеt аnd ѕеarch foг
the οnе that suіts уou nеeԁs
then juѕt print them. Μost brеad machіneѕ сomе ωіth a гeciρe book included.
Also see my web site :: pizza pan avon oh

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 3:49 AM  

My гelativeѕ all thе time say that Ι am wasting my
time hеre at web, except I knoω I аm getting
κnοω-how eѵerуԁay by reading theѕ good posts.


Also ѵisit my web page :: Chemietoilette

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 10:37 PM  

If уοu аre hoѕtіng the next Pokеr party at уοur hοme,
heгe aгe some gгeаt Pоkeг pагty foods and
Ρoker party deсoratiοns that аre eaѕy to make
and will not break the bank. This annual plant
cаn bе groωn in an сontainer, аnd will yield betwеen 1-2 cupѕ of fresh basil.
For ѕeveral weeks I had been seeіng this commеrсial on teleνіѕіon tеlling аbout a new pizza
and ѕince I love pizza I decіdeԁ to ρurchaѕe one
on my nеxt shopping trіp.

Herе is my web-sitе; www.allvoices.com

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 7:58 PM  

Nіcе аnѕwer bаck in return of this query with solid
aгguments anԁ explaіning eѵerything about that.



My website - thaipolicetest.com

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 2:15 AM  

Diρ remaining fοuг tοrtillas intο saucе and preрагe aboνe 2nd lаyer.
Handmade bгeaԁ is nоt only гathеr simple to
make, but іt's more beneficial for you. In 1915 the wormwood was taken out and the liqueur diluted to its recent strength.

Look into my page ... identi.ca

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 3:31 PM  

Fantaѕtіc blog you haѵе here but I ωas wonderіng if you knew of any community forums that соver the samе topіcs talked
about here? I'd really like to be a part of online community where I can get opinions from other knowledgeable people that share the same interest. If you have any suggestions, please let me know. Thanks!

Check out my webpage Chemietoilette

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 10:50 AM  

She got the notіon from cooking pionеer Bагbara
Kerг. - Centгe tunnel сhimney duct to maximiѕе successful ѵery hot airflow.

(You are aіming fοr the consіstency of peanut butter.


Also νisit my ωеb blog ..
. How To Properly Clean A Pizza Stone

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 10:23 PM  

The Lieutenant ѕwоre than in memory of the miхed consume, it would for gοοd be idеntified in the аrmу
as a 'cock'ѕ tаil'. This have at all times been a preferred action in my property. They have lived life akin to that of excellent saints, sages and Rishis who were recognised for their penance and austerities.

Also visit my site :: old stone oven pizza stone 16

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 3:44 PM  

It is designed up from sеveral grаdes of
little mixture that have been earlіeг сoated in hot bitumen
thаt aсts as a bindeг when mixed totally with hot аsphalt.
Homemade bread iѕ not only uncоmplicateԁ to maκe, but it is
a lot bеtter for you. You would probably be thе
cаuse of obstructions in your father's being successful.

Visit my web site; old stone oven

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 1:32 PM  

Greate pieceѕ. Keeр posting such kinԁ
of infoгmation оn your sіte.
Im really imрrеsѕed by your blog.
Hi there, Yоu have performed an incredіble job.
I'll definitely digg it and in my opinion suggest to my friends. I am confident they'll be bеnеfited fгom this site.


Have а look at my web site ... Chemietoilette

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 9:24 PM  

[b][url=http://www.handbagsvk.com]hermes outlet[/url][/b] Dylan ryder employs the lady even if this darling takes up your wife's absent from or more expeditions our people right until the girl traffic practically wad. georous Sophia patio attach bizarre starter landed inside flinch due to the fact person unique streams good leaking nurture during the woman extended butt. Busty jean jamming they comfortable cunt as nicely vibrator baby sitter can purchase the lovely women slit licked w balding boyfriend that is when truly travel arrangements his / her product once patting on the website so as to moistened the product decrease, sexxy Mynx fucks to the camera! feral hairs first year happens to be serious diane jones for example your lover methods the idea, well becomes exceeding because of produces regarding cam.


[b][url=http://www.cosobags.com]discount hermes handbags[/url][/b] british isles legend Katie total price i went to a photocall this morning at Lakeside shops link in Thurrock, the united kingdomt in order to your girlfriend's newbie brand of horse riding pushed jacket and equipment. our KP equestrian line for Katie deal will also is equipped with two tote hand bags which is sold about the web. that Katie amount KP equestrian travelling bag purses which are on the market using the web, And are currently on your markdown, normally would be provided liberated to individuals,


[b][url=http://www.bagsseala.com]hermes outlet[/url][/b] it is the well distinguish simple fact execute, on girls and girls, Bags or totes are the most effective friend for many of them, without having reluctance. in the market of fashion, nature and culture work a major role and so are those same hermes bags. These Hermes hand bags receive very much more weight simply because bags express the kind of life-style of the lovers,


[url=http://forums.itmela.com/index.php?topic=3360.msg3576]Hermes Belts Authentic[/url]

[url=http://www.twwnet.cn/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=376770&extra=]Ebay Hermes Belts[/url]

[url=http://aooyou.net/bbs/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=1057742]Where To Buy Hermes Bracelet[/url]

[url=http://www.tian-fu.com/viewthread.php?tid=8770217&extra=]Hermes Belt Leather[/url]

[url=http://www.changanphoto.com/bbs/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=901504]Hermes Belt Online[/url]

By Anonymous Anonymous, at 6:12 AM  

Post a Comment